Nobody wants tariffs until we need them

There are a lot of democrats and republicans that aren’t happy with the tariffs, but those who have lost great jobs and never found anything comparable think it’s about time we do something.

Ron Bourque ColumnistThere’s an old joke which illustrates a profound truth: “What’s the difference between a recession and a depression? A recession is when you lose your job, and a depression is when I lose mine.”

Nobody likes tariffs because they increase the prices of many of the things we buy. However, this doesn’t seem to be a red vs. blue issue. In my experience, the people in favor of tariffs, regardless of how painful they may be, are those who have lost good paying jobs to other countries. Many of them, especially in high tech, lost great jobs and never found anything comparable to what they had.

One day in a department store, I ran into an engineer that used to work with me. I noticed his badge indicating he was an employee of the store, and he was embarrassed. “Ron, this was the only thing I could find; I was running out of money.”

“Do you like it?”

“Are you kidding? I’m working 55 hours a week for a third of the money I used to make. The benefits, especially their health insurance, is a joke, and my wife has been sick. Forget about putting the kids through college; we might not even be able to keep the house.” His job, like many others went to China.

On December 8th, 1993, President Clinton signed the North American free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) eliminating most of our tariffs on Canada and Mexico. On December 8th, 1994, he signed The General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade (GATT) eliminating many of our tariffs with other countries. Unfortunately, very few of these countries reciprocated by eliminating their tariffs against us as they were supposed to.

We began hemorrhaging jobs like never before. We were literally exporting our jobs and our money in the name of free trade, but it was only free in one direction. Digital Equipment was the largest employer in New Hampshire and Massachusetts. That company, the second largest computer manufacturer in the world, doesn’t even exist anymore, and yes, all those jobs went to China.

Lucent Technologies had a massive plant in North Andover, MA. 12,500 People worked there many from New Hampshire, and yes, those jobs also migrated to the Far East. Because of those two treaties, all these things were happening at the same time, and those excellent, high-paying jobs went away. We exported our high-tech jobs and replaced them with retail and hamburger flipper jobs.

This continued year after year, and nobody did anything about it until recently. Whether you like him or not, President Trump is a very successful businessman, and he understands that no company or country can survive for long operating under such unfair circumstances.

There are a lot of democrats and republicans that aren’t happy with the tariffs, but those who have lost great jobs and never found anything comparable think it’s about time we do something.

It’s not a new problem. After the Revolutionary War when we won our independence, George Washington, our first President, instituted tariffs. Although we were free from British rule, he realized they could still tax us by adding taxes to everything we bought from them.

Washington was a wealthy man, and he bought the best, often coming from Britain. His coach, much of his furniture and clothes came from Britain. He felt the tariffs would enable U.S. companies to build better products here at home and compete more effectively with other companies all over the world.

It worked. Foreign buyers started buying products from U.S. companies and we eventually captured world markets on many products.

As I write this a few days after the election, it’s no secret that President Trump and the Republicans didn’t do well on November 3rd. Regardless, do we really think it’s a good idea to keep shipping our jobs and our money overseas? Our national debt is currently at $40.6 trillion. We can’t afford our standard of living anymore, so we’re continually borrowing.

Where do we think this is going to lead? Even if you think your job or business is secure, this is not sustainable, and neither is anything else.

Please, as you think about the issues, especially those that directly affect businesses and our ability to make a living, support what is good for our country and what is good for us regardless of who is driving it.

Ronald J. Bourque, a consultant and speaker from Salem, has had engagements throughout the United States, Europe and Asia. He can be reached at 603-898-1871 or RonBourque3@gmail.com. 

Categories: Business Advice, Workplace Advice