Scammers gonna scam

Police offer tips for avoiding fraud attempts

Gov. Kelly Ayotte speaks on Sept. 14 during a press conference at the Manchester Police Department about Senate Bill 482, a law that will go into effect in December against ATM crypto scams. (Photo by John Koziol)

As Taylor Swift might sing, scammers are gonna scam, scam, scam.

Legality aside, there’s good money to be made in scamming your fellow human being, say Manchester Police Det.

Ray Lamy and Mike Moyer, a former Laconia Police chief and Belknap County Sheriff.

They recognize that, while the techniques of scamming have changed and continue to evolve, the underlying premise remains the same and is as old as humanity itself: Some people would rather avail themselves of other people’s money rather than earn their own.

Authorities are stopping some scams — the Legislature earlier this year passed a law that make it easier for victims of crypto ATM scams to recoup some of their money — but artificial intelligence is giving scammers a new and powerful tool to do their dirty work.

During interviews with Lamy, who heads the MPD’s fraud unit and with Moyer, who is now an investigator with Goodridge Investigations, the men acknowledged that the scammers will always have a slight lead over those who want to rein them in.

Lamy and Moyer also believe, however, that the public can prevent a lot of grief and heartache, by adhering to the words of former President Ronald Reagan: Trust but verify.

Reagan famously invoked the Russian proverb during talks in the late 1980s with the former Soviet Union when told by Soviet leaders about what they claimed were things they were doing toward agreements with the U.S.

Verification of what a scammer is saying, usually by cross referencing it with a legitimate source, may foil some scams, Lamy and Moyer agree, but not all, which is why the public has to be constantly vigilant.

If you receive an unsolicited call, text or email that seeks money and seeks it urgently, like right away, the likelihood is high that you are being scammed.

“A lot of what I see,” said Lamy, “is impersonation,” where in a text message or phone call, a scammer either claims to be with a law-enforcement agency or to be working with one.

The reality, though, is that “Government agencies don’t work directly with private retail companies,” said Lamy. Sometimes, a scammer will claim in a pop-up message that they’re from Apple and that the message recipient’s Apple iPhone, for example, as well as the recipient’s identity, have been hijacked.

The scammer, Lamy continued, will then say something like “I’m going to put you in contact with the FBI,” when in reality, he is passing the person along to another participant in the scam.

Asked what a person should do after receiving a possible scam text, call or email, Lamy advises them to “just shut off your computer or phone. That’s it.”

When confronted by such an action, scammers will often search for another victim, said Lamy, because they are engaged in a numbers game — there are many potential victims out there — and time is of the essence to them.

The longer a would-be scam victim has to objectively consider what is happening and maybe even make a call to their bank, utility or friend to discuss it, the less likely it is that he or she will fall for the scam, Lamy said.

If you do call your bank or utility, both Lamy and Moyer stress that you first confirm that you are, indeed, calling a real bank or utility. Never, they say, call a number provided in the possible scam message, because scammers can “spoof” phone numbers so they seem like you’re calling a legitimate party, when that is not the case at all.

Scammers often imitate real businesses, said Lamy and Moyer, and may try to scam a business or even a local government.

In 2021, Moyer pointed out, the Town of Peterborough lost more than $2.3 million when scammers used forged documents to transfer money from the town to what was believed to be the local school district. Later, the scammers also stole a payment that was intended to go to a contractor who was working on a municipal project.

Should a scammer obtain a bill from a government or business, they can and often tell the scam victim that there has been a change in the bank routing number, said Lamy.

Those kinds of changes can be minute and therefore difficult to detect, he added, but they are significant and very consequential.

If you’ve been taken in by a scam that requires you to convert cash into crypto, the probability is high that your money is gone the moment the crypto has been sent, usually to a scammer who is located overseas and therefore outside the reach of American justice.

New Hampshire’s ATM crypto scam law, which goes into effect in December, protects consumers by creating a $2,000 daily transaction limit for all customers, according to the office of Gov. Kelly Ayotte, and requires a 48-hour hold on a customer’s first transaction, “allowing the transaction to be canceled and refunded during that period, and provides a full refund for fraudulent transactions reported within 14 days after the transaction is completed.”

In Manchester, there are a dozen places where cash can be converted into crypto and electronically sent to possible scammers, said Lamy. The owners of the crypto ATM machines can earn up to 30% from each transaction, he said, while the owners of the businesses where the ATMs are located get paid a flat fee for hosting them.

The crypto scam ATM law is “very good compared to what we had,” Lamy said. “It’s not going to stop the fraud from happening, but it will limit the exposure.”

Lamy cautioned the public to be aware of several scam red flags, including that the contact is originating from overseas. Also, he said, “a legitimate business or government agency won’t ask for crypto or gift cards. They won’t ask for cash or money, regardless.”

Lamy said that, in his experience, financial crimes have been increasing, “and I don’t expect that it will slow down, especially with the technology that is benefitting criminals.”

Consumers can “put a freeze on their credit,” he said, and they can also put a freeze on their banking records, but those actions are “not infallible.”

Don’t let anyone remotely access your computer, Lamy said, and never “give your user name and password to anybody. Those are the broad strokes.” The bottom line, he summed up, is to question “anything financially related that you didn’t” authorize or initiate.

The NH Banking Department (at www.banking.nh.gov/consumer-assistance/avoiding-scams-and-fraud) tells the public in great detail about scams and how to avoid them.

Moyer, who was Laconia’s police chief from 2007-2011 and served as Belknap County’s elected sheriff from 2017-2021, echoed Lamy, saying, “One of the tip-offs that something is a scam is that it’s always urgent.”

In real life, most situations can be addressed in due time, “But any time it’s ‘urgent,’” said Moyer, “say ‘OK,’ and take a deep breath,” and verify what is being told to you.

And, he added, never verify the claim with information provided by the would-be scammer.

Instead, “pick up the phone and go to the real website” to independently confirm that you are, indeed, speaking with your bank or business with which you have dealt with before, said Moyer.

Businesses should train their staff in how to prevent “business email compromise (BEC).” He noted that some businesses have actually “phished” their employees to educate them about the problem.

The BEC training has to be done regularly and “done more than once,” said Moyer. “You can’t have enough training.”

Yes, he said, training and verification are important, “but it’s getting scary now” with how technology is being misused by scammers.

“Any time you see ‘we need this now,’” take that as a warning that you are being scammed, Moyer said.

In 2024, the FBI found that more than 2,000 Granite Staters had fallen prey to internet crimes, with Moyer pointing out that those crimes were viewed less harshly by law enforcement than physical robberies.

But the tide is turning. “Yes, people do get hurt” by scams, said Moyer, be they individuals, businesses or governments.

Criminals can make “a whole lot of money,” he said, thanks to the internet and smartphones.

Scammers don’t even have to be particularly innovative. The practice of defrauding someone else has “always been with us,” said Moyer.

“There’ve been scams since the first person walked the Earth, and it’s only going to get bigger.”

Categories: In Focus, Law, News, Technology