Anatomy of a DEAL

No one size fits all

You’re the owner and president of a medium-sized manufacturing company in New Hampshire.

You make advanced-tech, precision materials for some large-scale companies, also located here and elsewhere, that produce defense- and military-related products.

You have a roster of 40 employees and will assuredly need a dozen more if your planned 6,000-square-foot addition to your plant gets the OK from local officials.

Your company has been around since you created it some 35 years ago, adapting to new technologies, investing in infrastructure, tailoring your output to the needs of your clients.

But you’re on the other side of 70 years old. You’re looking for an exit.

Where do you even start?

It’s a question that eventually confronts every company owner, and, according to a variety of local experts in the field of mergers and acquisitions, there is no cookie-cutter, one-size-fits-all approach.

“It’s incredibly complex. There is quite a spectrum of different options externally for a sale,” said Michelline Dufort, director of the CEO & Family Enterprise Center at the University of New Hampshire. “It’s not one size fits all at all.”

There are questions a CEO has to ask themselves that ultimately set the compass on the direction the sale might go.

Is it a succession transaction to a son or daughter or some other relative to maintain the family legacy in the business? Is it a cash sale to a private equity company? Is it a sale to company employees? Is it an asset sale or a stock sale? Is it a merger with another company?

But the very first question is about the owner.

As John Ela, a CEO coach, put it: “Who am I going to be?”

“That’s kind of true to anybody who is going through a transition, like say retirement,” said Ela, who created the Ela Management Group in Manchester in 2014. “But, with retirement, you thought of yourself as: ‘I work at IBM.’ It’s not: ‘I am IBM,’ and that’s a big factor in how hard that decision is.”

For many company founders, their business is their life, according to Ken Schaefer, a mergers and acquisition advisor at Touchstone Advisors in Concord.

“Some people worry about who will they be if they sell the company,” Schaefer said. “Their persona, their self image is wrapped up in the company.”

Aging workforce, aging owners

As New Hampshire’s workforce has been aging, contributing to the fact that the state by median age is the second oldest in the country (alongside Vermont and behind Maine), so have sole owners of some Granite State companies also been aging.

“Everyone has seen this bubble coming,” Dufort said. “This is just demographics. It’s just where things are, and there is a huge bubble of owners facing some big decisions.”


John Ela

‘The things that drive value … is something that company owners often don’t think about on their own.’

— John Ela


Lawyer Dennis Haley sees this in the private equity interest in companies involved in such trades as HVAC, plumbing and electrical. Owners of legacy trade companies want out, and private equity companies want in.

“They want to buy those businesses and bring a level of professional management to them that you know a mom-and-pop might not have had,” said Haley, who chairs McLane Middleton’s corporate department and is director of the law firm’s Manchester office.

“If you had a buyer that had significant capital behind them to come in, buy several of them, get big, bring a level of professional management and resources to them, and then sell them to somebody bigger; there’s a lot of that happening,” Haley said.


Michelline Dufort

‘It’s incredibly complex. There is quite a spectrum of different options externally for a sale.’

— Michelline Dufort


Owners’ decisions about their post-sale life will color the type of sale: Do they walk away with a bundle of cash and retire to a boating life in Florida? Do they structure a sale where they take a certain amount of money up front, but work part-time then take the rest after a transition period?

“From the seller’s point of view, the founder who’s thinking about retirement, not sure what he wants to do, been with the company a long time, the first thing to think about: What are his objectives? Does he want to get out completely, or does he want to possibly stay on board for a certain period of time to facilitate a transition?” said Jamie Hage, business attorney with Rath, Young and Pignatelli in Concord.

It is a fundamental question that all owners have to answer, according to Haley.

“You tell me what you want. Is that to maximize value? Is it to move the business to the kids? Is it, ‘I don’t want to be doing this full time anymore, but I still want something to do, so having the buyer keep me around for three years is important,’” Haley said. “I always like to start with: You tell me what you want, and we’ll figure out a way to make that happen.”

Few owners can just walk away and not look back, according to Schaefer.

“For some people, the company is their life. In other words, there are no hobbies. They work probably more than is prudent, and all of a sudden you turn that off. There should be a plan for that,” he said.

Dufort suggests owners create what she calls a “personal balance sheet.”

“They are so commingled with their company that where it begins and where it ends is sometimes hard to tell,” Dufort said. “So we advise owners to get themselves a personal balance sheet to think about: If that switch flips tomorrow, what’s your life going to look like financially? What is intermingled with the company for your own personal needs? Whether it’s your car; there’s so many different ways to look at this.”

First on the checklist: value

All the experts interviewed for this story recommend that an owner assemble a team when considering a sale. That team should include: a lawyer who specializes in mergers and acquisitions, an accountant, a wealth management advisor and a management advisor/coach experienced in mergers and acquisitions.

“I think a lot of these business owners think that they’re supposed to know everything, and I always say to a business owner, ‘Hey, would you draw up the biggest contract of your life without a lawyer?’ Well, of course not,” Dufort said. “Then why do you think you would make the biggest decision for your business of your life without experts at your right elbow? It’s OK. There are people who do this work really, really well and do it delicately.”

These experts will have a checklist, and at the top is determining a value for the company. Then it becomes an exercise in matching the value the owner expects against what the owner expects the value to mean after the sale.

“He’s got to wrap his head around what’s the value of his business? These deals can be structured in a variety of ways,” Hage said.

A company’s value can have many components. It’s not only the value of the property that the founder may own, or the value of the equipment in his shop. The value can also include a workforce particularly skilled to a certain craft. It might include patents and trade secrets. It includes the concentration of current clients and potential clients in the event of a sale.


Jamie Hage

‘These deals can be structured in a variety of ways.’

— Jamie Hage


“Talking about the things that drive value — a strong management team, ability to run without the owner, not having customer concentration or vendor concentration, how to reduce the risk — is something that company owners often don’t think about on their own,” Ela said.

Sooner is better than later

The decision to sell can be driven by extreme circumstances, such as an illness or some other emergency. For the most part, however, owners thinking about selling should give themselves a big block of time to plan and execute.

“The more time, the better,” said Haley, who added that certain strategies involving the value of a sale come down to timing.

In the scenario outlined above, for example, Haley said perhaps the owner will want to finish the buildout of his proposed expansion and run the expanded operation for a few more years before putting the business on the market.

“Don’t let your buyer get the advantage of your permits and approval. You don’t want to finish this buildout, do all that work, and then sell the company, and have the buyer get the advantage of all of that,” Haley said. “You might want to run it for a year or two, increase your profits and sell it for more.”

“I’d say three to five years,” answered Ela when asked how long, ideally, should an owner plan in advance for a sale.


Ken Schaefer

‘Some people worry about who will they be if they sell the company.’

— Ken Schaefer


“And the difference between three and five is how much change needs to happen, both in the mind of the owner and in how the company operates,” he added. “If you have a chaotic company that’s highly dependent on the owner for key customer and supplier relationships as the secret sauce, or is it that they’ve got a weak management team and they’re making all the decisions? That’s going to greatly reduce their ability to sell, let alone the value, and fixing that takes time.”

Honesty is the best policy

The process to get to a sale will lay bare not only the business but, to a large extent, the owner. So the team members — the lawyers and the advisors, for instance — don’t want surprises, especially at the 11th hour.

“When I say I want you to get your money and keep your money, then telling me everything is part of keeping your money,” Haley said.

He notes there are representations and warranties — basically legal promises — an owner makes as part of an agreement: that there’s no pending litigation, that the audit findings are accurate, that it is in compliance with all local, state and federal tax regulations, that its contracts continue to be valid, that the company holds the valid trademarks and/or patents relative to its business, etc.

If there’s a known issue — a demand letter from a customer, for instance — resolving it can be part of the agreement, according to Haley, through an earnout: the buyer withholds part of the purchase price and holds it in escrow, then once the issue is resolved, the balance is paid.

“Being open with it is the way to protect yourself,” Haley said.

Knowing provides the opportunity for work-arounds, according to Hage.

“Don’t hold anything back. When it comes to that, one of the things we hate to see are surprises,” he said.

“It’s better to know. And this is from a lawyer’s perspective: It’s better to know everything that the client has, even if some of the stuff isn’t good, and then we can work around that,” he added.

Which underscores the need to have a team at the ready when the time comes to sell, according to Ela.


Dennis Haley

‘You tell me what you want, and we’ll figure out a way to make that happen.’

— Dennis Haley


“Running a business, particularly one that you’ve started, you’re really focusing very much on the day to day: How do I meet payroll? How do I get product out the door? How do I get new customers? How do I grow? How do I not grow too fast?

“And you’re balancing all of these things, and the idea of creating enterprise value, meaning not this month’s profit but long-term value to a buyer, is a really different set of questions that they often don’t ask,” Ela said.

Categories: In Focus, News