Ratepayers lose in Eversource deal


To the editor:

Your analysis of the settlement deal (“Behind the big deal,” July 23-Aug. 4 NH Business Review) was short on analysis of the impacts on Ever­source ratepayers. The deal puts the cost of the scrubber at $415 million and counting on the ratepayers, plus $130 million of over market costs of the Berlin PPA on ratepayers, plus the mercury and PCB cleanup costs at Schiller estimated at $30 million and likely much more than that, plus the other labor, tax and other costs described in the settlement papers. The rub here is that the scrubber did not go operational until late 2011 and a little over two years later, Mer­rimack Station was appraised at $10 million by LaCapra, the PUC-com­missioned appraiser, not an example of prudent company management. The “cost savings” promoted as the impetus for the deal is smoke. The “savings” assume that the fossil facili­ties remain operational out into the future and that Eversource continues to collect its 9.5+ percent return (out of which comes the $25 million in “givebacks”). The assumption, of course, is il­lusory because it was Eversource that decided that the plants were no longer economic to operate and it wanted to divest them. The politicians who promoted this deal, Hassan, Bradley and Feltes, did the ratepayers no favors. Ratepayers will be paying these “stranded” costs” for years.

Arthur B. Cunningham

More opinion pieces and letters to the editor

The governor, and the state, are at an energy crossroads

Change is inevitable, despite the efforts of outside interests

Hey solar industry, why the subsidy?

We should not be trying to artificially grow an industry by holding ratepayers hostage

BIA roundtables offer a chance to shape priorities

How business leaders from around NH form the organization’s legislative agenda

To save ratepayers, let renewables compete

Net metering helps the governor meet his promise of cutting energy costs

New Hampshire needs net metering expansion

Why Governor Sununu should sign Senate Bill 446
Edit ModuleShow Tags
Edit ModuleShow Tags